Sol Stein does not believe in encouraging writers. He’s here to teach, full stop. Stein has been an editor and a writer for years and clearly knows his craft, but in his desire to deliver straightforward instruction, he’s stripped out all the helpfulness as well. I always admire good practical instruction, but not when it’s delivered so harshly and dogmatically that I can’t take it in.
Stein is quite long-winded and it takes him forever to make a point, which is sad because he’s not saying anything new. Some say STEIN ON WRITING is “timeless” but that’s another way of saying it’s old hat.
Even so, STEIN ON WRITING is thorough and full of solid information and decent examples. He covers things like the intersection of character and plot, cutting flab during revision, the basics of good dialog, and the importance of suspense. He also shows how and when fiction techniques should be applied to non-fiction.
This is all important stuff that writers need, but it’s presented in such a condescending package I could barely get through it. The best teachers empower students, while Stein seems to find us hopeless. While reading STEIN ON WRITING, I got the feeling that Stein was sharing specific writing techniques not so that we can employ them in our own novels, but simply to show us how much he knows.
Writers pick up how-to books with a sincere desire to learn. I’m not asking to be coddled, but I don’t need to be talked down to, either. I’m a professional writer, and with so many how-to books already on my shelf, I have little time for books that don’t treat me with respect.
STEIN ON WRITING can be found here.
Rating: 2 stars
I recommend Writing The Novel From Plot to Print to Pixel by Lawrence Block or Writing Fiction for All You’re Worth by James Scott Bell instead of this book.